Revenue Reconciliation Act p5

Home Services FAQ Site Map Contact Us

Articles by Alvin Brown
Tax Preparation
Offer In Compromise
State Offers in Compromise
Levy
IRS Tax Liens
IRS Tax Liens - continued
IRS Tax Liens - continued 2
Levy - continued
Audit Techniques Guide
Congressional Contacts
Criminal Investigation
D.O.J Criminal Tax Manual
Tax Litigation
Penalty
Installment Agreements
Statute of Limitations
Frivolous Tax Argument
Interest Abatement
IRS Misconduct
IRS Abuses
Tax Fraud
Fraud Statutes
Bankruptcy
Tax Reform Legislation
Tax Shelters
Tax Court
Trust Fund Penalty
Legislation
Innocent Spouse Relief
Important Links

Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p1
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p2
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p3
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p4
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p5
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p6
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p7
Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 p8
Revenue Reconciliation Act p1
Revenue Reconciliation Act p2
Revenue Reconciliation Act p3
Revenue Reconciliation Act p4
Revenue Reconciliation Act p5
Revenue Reconciliation Act p6
Revenue Reconciliation Act p7
Revenue Reconciliation Act p8
Revenue Reconciliation Act p9
Revenue Reconciliation Act p10
RRA 1998 Conference Report p1
RRA 1998 Conference Report p2
RRA 1998 Conference Report p3
RRA 1998 Conference Report p4
RRA 1998 Conference Report p5
RRA 1998 Conference Report p6
RRA 1998 Conference Report p7
Changes in Existing Law
RRA 1998 Senate Report p1
RRA 1998 Senate Report p2
RRA 1998 Senate Report p3
RRA 1998 Senate Report p4
RRA 1998 Senate Report p5
RRA 1998 Senate Report p6
RRA 1998 Senate Report p7
RRA 1998 Senate Report p8
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p1
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p2
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p3
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p4
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p5
RRA 1998 House Ways Report p6
Report on HR 4297
Tax Reform Act of 2005
Tax Relief Act of 2005

 

Revenue Reconciliation Act page5

Back Next

4. Establish IRS continuous levy and improve debt collection (secs. 834, 835, and 836 of the bill and secs. 6331 and 6334 of the Code)

a. Continuous levy

Present Law



If any person is liable for any internal revenue tax and does not pay it within 10 days after notice and demand89 by the IRS, the IRS may then collect the tax by levy upon all property and rights to property belonging to the person,90 unless there is an explicit statutory restriction on doing so. A levy is the seizure of the person's property or rights to property. Property that is not cash is sold pursuant to statutory requirements.91

In general, a levy does not apply to property acquired after the date of the levy,92 regardless of whether the property is held by the taxpayer or by a third party (such as a bank) on behalf of a taxpayer. Successive seizures may be necessary if the initial seizure is insufficient to satisfy the liability.93 The only exception to this rule is for salary and wages.94 A levy on salary and wages is continuous from the date it is first made until the date it is fully paid or becomes unenforceable.

A minimum exemption is provided for salary and wages.95 It is computed on a weekly basis by adding the value of the standard deduction plus the aggregate value of personal exemptions to which the taxpayer is entitled, divided by 52.96 For a family of four for taxable year 1996, the weekly minimum exemption is $325.97


Reasons for Change



The extension of the continuous levy provisions will substantially ease the administrative burdens of collecting taxes by levy. The Committee anticipates that taxpayers who already comply with the tax laws will have a positive view of increased collections of taxes owed by taxpayers who have not complied with the tax laws.


Explanation of Provision



The provision amends the Code to provide that a continuous levy is also applicable to non-means tested recurring Federal payments. This is defined as a Federal payment for which eligibility is not based on the income and/or assets of a payee. For example, Social Security payments, which are subject to levy under present law, would become subject to continuous levy.

In addition, the provision provides that this levy would attach up to 15 percent of any specified payment due the taxpayer. This rule explicitly replaces the other specifically enumerated exemptions from levy in the Code. A continuous levy of up to 15 percent would also apply to unemployment benefits and means-tested public assistance.

The bill also permits the disclosure of otherwise confidential tax return information to the Treasury Department's Financial Management Service only for the purpose of, and to the extent necessary in, implementing these levy provisions.


Effective Date



The provision is effective for levies issued after the date of enactment.


b. Modifications of levy exemptions




Present Law



The Code exempts from levy workmen's compensation payments,98 unemployment benefits99 and means-tested public assistance.100


Reasons for Change



The Committee believes that if wages are subject to levy, wage replacement payments should also be subject to levy.


Explanation of Provision



The provision provides that the following property is not exempt from continuous levy if the Secretary of the Treasury (or his delegate) approves the levy of such property:

(1) workmen's compensation payments,

(2) unemployment benefits, and

(3) means-tested public assistance.


Effective Date



The provision applies to levies issued after the date of enactment.


E. Excise Tax Provisions




1. Extension and modification of Airport and Airway Trust Fund excise taxes (sec. 841 of the bill and secs. 4081, 4091, and 4261 of the Code)




Present Law



Present law imposes a variety of excise taxes on air transportation to finance the Airport and Airway Trust Fund programs administered by the Federal Aviation Administration (the "FAA"). In general, the full cost of FAA capital programs is financed from the Airport and Airway Trust Fund, while only a portion of FAA operational expenses is Trust Fund-financed. Overall, the portion of total FAA expenditures that has been financed from the Trust Fund has declined from 75 percent through the early 1990s to 62 percent for the 1997 fiscal year. The balance is financed by general taxpayers, rather than directly by program users. Each of the Airport and Airway Trust Fund excise taxes is scheduled to expire after September 30, 1997.


Commercial air passenger transportation taxes



Domestic air passenger transportation is subject to an ad valorem excise tax equal to 10 percent of the amount paid for the transportation. Taxable domestic air transportation includes both travel within the United States and certain travel between the United States and points in Canada or Mexico that are within 225 miles of the U.S. border (the "225-mile zone").

Special rules apply to air transportation between the continental United States and Alaska or Hawaii and between Alaska and Hawaii . The portion of such transportation which is not within the United States (e.g., the portion over the Pacific Ocean between the continental West Coast and Hawaii) is not subject to the 10-percent air passenger excise tax.101 The 10-percent excise tax applies in full, however, to air transportation within the States of Alaska and Hawaii .

The 10-percent air passenger transportation excise tax also does not apply to domestic U.S. segments of uninterrupted international air transportation. Uninterrupted international air transportation includes only travel (entirely by air) that does not both begin and end in the United States (or in the 225-mile zone) and during which there is no more than a 12-hour scheduled period between arrival and departure at any intermediate point in the United States . For example, assume that a passenger travels from New York to Tokyo , with a four-hour stop and aircraft change in Seattle . The domestic segment of the flight (i.e., New York to Seattle ) is not subject to the domestic air passenger transportation excise tax because that segment is a part of uninterrupted international air transportation.

International air passenger transportation is subject to a $6 departure excise tax imposed on passengers departing the United States for other countries. No tax is imposed on passengers arriving in the United States from other countries. As with passengers departing the United States , separate domestic flights of arriving passengers that connect from international flights are exempt from tax, provided that stopover time at any point within the United States does not exceed 12 hours.

Because both the domestic and international air passenger excise taxes are imposed only on transportation for which an amount is paid, no tax is imposed on "free" travel (e.g., frequent flyer travel and airline industry employee travel for which the passenger is not directly charged).

The air passenger transportation excise taxes are imposed on passengers; transportation providers (generally airlines) are responsible for collecting and remitting the taxes to the Federal Government. In general, both the domestic and international air passenger transportation excise taxes are imposed without regard to whether the transportation is purchased within the United States . An exception provides that travel between the United States and the 225-mile zone is subject to the ad valorem domestic tax only if it is purchased within the United States .

The amount of air passenger transportation excise tax collected from a passenger must be stated separately on the ticket.


Commercial air cargo transportation



Domestic air cargo transportation is subject to a 6.25-percent ad valorem excise tax. This tax, like the air passenger excise taxes, is imposed on the consumer, with the transportation provider being required to collect and remit the tax to the Federal Government. However, there is no requirement that the tax be stated separately on shipping invoices.


Noncommercial aviation



Noncommercial aviation, or transportation on private aircraft which is not "for hire," is subject to excise taxes imposed on fuel in lieu of the commercial air passenger ticket and air cargo excise taxes. The current Airport and Airway Trust Fund tax rates on these fuels are 15 cents per gallon on aviation gasoline and 17.5 cents per gallon on jet fuel.

The aviation gasoline excise tax is imposed on removal of the fuel from a registered terminal facility (the same point as the highway gasoline excise tax). The jet fuel excise tax is imposed on sale of the fuel by a wholesale distributor. Many larger airports have dedicated pipeline facilities that directly service aircraft; in such a case, the tax effectively is imposed at the retail level. The person removing the gasoline from a terminal facility or the wholesale distributor of the jet fuel is liable for these taxes.


Deposit of air transportation excise taxes



Under present law, the air passenger ticket and freight excise taxes are collected from passengers and freight shippers by the commercial air carriers. The air carriers then remit the funds to the Treasury Department; however, the air carriers are not required to remit monies immediately. Excise tax returns are filed quarterly (similar to annual income tax returns), with taxes being deposited on a semi-monthly basis (similar to estimated income taxes). For air transportation sold during a semi-monthly period, air carriers may elect to treat the taxes as collected on the last day of the first week of the second following semi-monthly period. Under these "deemed collected" rules, for example, the taxes on air transportation sold between August 1 and August 15, are treated as collected by the air carriers on or before September 7, with the amounts generally being deposited with the Treasury Department by September 10. A special rule requires certain amounts deemed collected during the second half of September to be deposited by September 29.

Semi-monthly deposits and quarterly excise tax returns also are required with respect to the fuels excise taxes imposed on air transportation.


Overflight user fees



Non-tax user fees are imposed on air transportation (both commercial and noncommercial aviation) that travels through airspace for which the United States provides air traffic control services, but that neither lands in nor takes off from a point in the United States . These fees are imposed and collected by the FAA with respect to mileage actually flown, and apply both to travel within U.S. territorial airspace and to travel within international oceanic airspace for which the United States is responsible for providing air traffic control services.


Reasons for Change



The Committee determined that provisions to ensure a long-term, stable funding source for the Airport and Airway Trust Fund should be enacted at this time. As illustrated by the recent events when a shortfall in fiscal year 1997 FAA funding was narrowly averted by an emergency extension of the present-law excise taxes through September 30, 1997, longer-term assurance of these funding needs is imperative. Therefore, the bill extends (with certain modifications) the current Airport and Airway Trust Fund excise taxes for a 10-year period, a move that it is believed will resolve, for this 10-year period, concerns about the availability of adequate user tax revenues to fund the portion of FAA programs to be appropriated from the Airport and Airway Trust Fund.

The Committee determined that limited modifications to the current passenger excise tax structure are warranted to improve the perceived fairness of these taxes. First, the Committee was very concerned that, under present law, passengers traveling in international transportation pay significantly less tax for transportation involving comparable FAA services than do entirely domestic passengers. The Committee believes it unfair for American families traveling domestically on, e.g., family vacations, to be required to subsidize persons engaged in this international travel. In particular, the Committee is extremely concerned that domestic passengers flying on entirely domestic flights currently are exempt from tax if they connect to or from another, international flight while passengers on the same flight who do not go on to or arrive from an international destination are fully taxed. Similarly, the Committee believes it is inappropriate that passengers arriving in the United States should not pay any tax for the FAA services they receive. To achieve greater equity in the air transportation user taxes, the bill extends the tax to internationally arriving passengers, reclassifies domestic segments of international travel as domestic transportation, and clarifies that the tax applies to payments to airlines (and related parties) from credit card and other companies in exchange for the right to award frequent flyer miles or other reduced air travel rights.

The Committee further believes that continued availability of air transportation services to rural areas is an important national objective. Accordingly, the bill provides a special, reduced tax rate for flight segments to and from smaller rural airports.


Explanation of Provisions




Extension of Airport and Airway Trust Fund taxes



The Airport and Airway Trust Fund excise taxes, as modified below, are extended for 10 years, for the period October 1, 1997, through September 30, 2007. The taxes that are extended include the domestic and international air passenger excise taxes, the air cargo excise tax, and the noncommercial aviation fuels taxes. Gross receipts from these taxes will continue to be deposited in the Airport and Airway Trust Fund.


Modification of commercial air passenger transportation taxes



Tax on international arrivals and departures; treatment of domestic flight segments associated with international travel. --The current $6 international departure tax is increased to $8 per departure, and an identical $8 per passenger tax is imposed on arrivals in the United States from international locations. The definition of international transportation is modified to eliminate domestic flight segments associated with that travel (which are taxed the same as other domestic transportation under the bill). Thus, the $8 per passenger tax applies to all uninterrupted flight segments between a point in the United States and a point in a foreign country.

Under the bill, domestic flight segments associated with international transportation are taxed the same as other domestic flights. Domestic flight segments are flight segments between two U.S. points (or between a U.S. point and a point within the 225-mile zone) from which the passenger continues to or from an international flight. The 10-percent domestic tax rate applies to all such flight segments. The portion of a passenger's fare that is subject to this tax is equal to the percentage of total travel miles covered by the fare (determined based on the aggregate number of miles in all of the flight segments) that the domestic flight segment miles comprise. For this purpose, flight miles are "Great Circle" miles unless the Treasury Department develops another measure (such as predominate routed mileage). Great Circle miles are based on the shortest distance (i.e., "as the crow flies") between two points. In general, this mileage calculation is identical to that which is used by frequent flyer programs offered by all major U.S. airlines today. Computer programs are readily available for calculating "Great Circle" miles between origin and destination points for flights.

These provisions are illustrated by the following example. Assume that a passenger travels from Paris to Los Angeles with a intermediate stop and aircraft change in New York . The passenger is subject to an $8 tax on the flight segment from Paris to New York . Assume further that 50 percent of the aggregate miles on the London to Los Angeles trip are attributable to travel between New York and Los Angeles . In this case, 50 percent of the fare is subject to the 10-percent ad valorem tax for the flight segment between New York and Los Angeles . The combined tax amount (international and domestic rate portions) are calculated by the airline and stated on the passenger's ticket.

Special rules applicable to certain transportation. --Transportation between the 48 contiguous States and Alaska or Hawaii (or between those States) remains subject to the special rules provided in present law. Thus, this transportation is taxed on apportioned mileage in U.S. territorial airspace plus $6 per passenger per one-way flight.102 Clarification is provided that only one $6 per passenger tax is imposed on a single flight segment (despite the fact that such a flight segment technically constitutes both an international departure and an international arrival).

Additionally, the current special provisions governing transportation between the United States and points within the 225-mile zone of Canada or Mexico are retained, with that transportation being taxed on the same basis as other domestic transportation in the circumstances provided under present law (as modified by the provisions of the bill recharacterizing certain domestic flight segments associated with international transportation).

A further special rule is provided for certain flight segments to or from qualified rural airports. A qualified rural airport is an airport that (1) in the second preceding calendar year had fewer than 100,000 commercial passenger enplanements (i.e., departures), and (2) either (a) is not located within 75 miles of another airport that had more than 100,000 such passenger enplanements in that year, or (b) is eligible for payments under the Federal "essential air services" program (as in effect on the date of enactment). Flight segments to or from a qualified rural airport are subject to a reduced, 7.5-percent ad valorem rate (in lieu of the general 10-percent rate).103 The term flight segment is defined as transportation involving a single take-off and a single landing. In the case of transportation involving multiple flight segments, the portion of the fare allocable to the rural segment is determined based on the number of Great Circle miles in the rural flight segment as compared to the aggregate number of miles in all of the flight segments. This is the same calculation that is used in apportioning international transportation between taxable international travel and associated domestic flight segments.

Extension of tax to certain currently exempt passengers. --As described above, passengers arriving in the United States from other countries, who currently are the only group of travelers whose transportation is subject neither to an excise tax nor a user fee for U.S.-provided aviation services, are subject to tax on their arriving international flights. Similarly, passengers traveling on domestic flight segments that either connect to or from international flight segments are subject to tax in the same manner as other, entirely domestic passengers.

Clarification further is provided that any amounts paid to air carriers (in cash or in kind) for the right to award or otherwise distribute free or reduced-rate air transportation are treated as amounts paid for taxable air transportation, subject to the 10-percent ad valorem tax rate. Examples of such taxable amounts include (1) payments for frequent flyer miles purchased by credit card companies, telephone companies, rental car companies, television networks, restaurants and hotels, and other businesses for distribution to their customers and others (e.g., employees) and (2) amounts received by airlines pursuant to joint venture credit card or other marketing arrangements. The Treasury Department is authorized specifically to disregard accounting allocations or other arrangements which have the effect of reducing artificially the base to which the 10-percent tax is applied. (No inference is intended from this provision as to the proper treatment of these payments under present law.)

Liability for tax. --The present-law provision imposing liability for the tax on passengers (with transportation providers being liable for collecting and remitting revenues to the Federal Government) are modified to impose secondary liability on air carriers. As with the current tax, the aggregate tax will continue to be required to be stated separately on passenger tickets.

Modification of air passenger excise tax deposit rules. --The deposit rules with respect to the commercial air passenger excise taxes are modified to permit payment of these taxes that otherwise would have been required to be deposited during the period August 15, 1997 through September 30, 1997, to be deposited on October 10, 1997. Similarly, tax deposits that would be due during the period July 1, 2001, through September 30, 2001, are required to be made no later than October 10, 2001.


Effective Date



These provisions generally are effective on the date of enactment, for air transportation beginning after September 30, 1997.

Present law requires transportation providers to continue collecting the commercial aviation excise taxes (at the current rates) on transportation to be provided after September 30, 1997, if the transportation is purchased before October 1, 1997. The bill requires transportation providers to collect the taxes at the modified rates for transportation purchased after the date of enactment for travel beginning after September 30, 1997.

The extension of the general aviation fuels excise taxes is effective for fuels removed or sold after September 30, 1997.

The provision clarifying application of the commercial air passenger excise tax to certain amounts paid for the right to award air transportation is effective for amounts paid (or benefits transferred) after September 30, 1997. A special rule provides that payments (or transfers) between related parties occurring after June 16, 1997 and before October 1, 1997, are subject to tax if the payments relate to rights to transportation to be awarded or otherwise distributed after September 30, 1997.

The modifications to the commercial air passenger excise tax deposit rules are effective on the date of enactment.


2. Reinstate Leaking Underground Storage Tank Trust Fund excise tax (sec. 842 of the bill and secs. 4041(d), 4081(a)(2), and 4081(d)(2) of the Code)




Present Law



Before January 1, 1996, an excise tax of 0.1 cent per gallon was imposed on gasoline, diesel fuel (including train diesel fuel), special motor fuels (other than liquefied petroleum gas), aviation fuels, and inland waterways fuels. Revenues from the tax were dedicated to the Leaking Underground Storage Tank Trust Fund to finance cleanups of leaking underground storage tanks.


Reasons for Change



The Committee determined that the Leaking Underground Storage Tank Trust Fund excise tax should be reinstated to ensure the availability of funds to pay cleanup costs of leaking underground storage tanks.


Explanation of Provision



The bill reinstates the prior-law Leaking Underground Storage Tank Trust Fund excise tax through September 30, 2007.


Effective Date



The provision is effective on October 1, 1997.


3. Application of communications tax to long-distance prepaid telephone cards (sec. 843 of the bill and sec. 4251 of the Code)




Present Law



A 3-percent excise tax is imposed on amounts paid for local and toll (long-distance) telephone service and teletypewriter exchange service. The tax is collected by the provider of the service from the consumer (business and residential custormers).


Reasons for Change



The Committee understands that communication service providers sometimes sell units of long-distance service to third parties who, in turn, resell or distribute these units of long-distance telephone service to the ultimate customer in the form of prepaid telephone cards or similar arrangements. The Committee believes that such payments clearly represent payments for long-distance telephone service and clarifies that such payments are subject to the communications excise tax.


Explanation of Provision



The bill provides that any amounts paid to telephone carriers (in cash or in kind) for the right to award or otherwise distribute long-distance telephone service, including free or reduced-rate service, are treated as amounts paid for taxable communication services, subject to the 3-percent ad valorem tax rate. Examples of such taxable amounts include (1) prepaid telephone cards offered through service stations, convenience stores and other businesses to their customers and others (e.g., employees) and (2) amounts received by telephone carriers pursuant to joint venture credit card or other marketing arrangements.

For example, company A, which is a telephone carrier that owns telephone transmission and switching equipment and generally offers telephone service to the public, may sell a block of long-distance message units to company B for X dollars. Company B owns no transmission or switching equipment, but rather acts a reseller of long distance telephone services and also is a telephone carrier. Company B, in turn, resells all or part of the long-distance message units purchased from Company A to Company C for Y dollars. Company C operates a chain of convenience stores. Company C resells some of the long-distance message units in the form of prepaid telephone cards to its convenience store customers and also makes some of the message units available to its employees as a benefit by the free distribution of such prepaid telephone cards to the employees. The amount Y will be considered an amount paid for telecommunications services subject to the 3-percent telephone excise tax. Alternatively, if company C had purchased the block of message units directly from company A for X dollars, the amount X will be considered an amount paid for telecommunications services subject to the 3-percent telephone excise tax.

In the case of amounts received by telecommunications carriers pursuant to joint venture credit card or other marketing arrangements, the Treasury Department is authorized specifically to disregard accounting allocations or other arrangements which have the effect of reducing artificially the base to which the 3-percent tax is applied.

No inference is intended from this provision as to the proper treatment of these payments under present law.


Effective Date



The provision is effective for amounts paid on or after the date of enactment.


4. Uniform rate of excise tax on vaccines (sec. 844 of the bill and secs. 4131 and 4132 of the Code)




Present Law



Under section 4131, a manufacturer's excise tax is imposed on the following vaccines routinely recommended for administration to children: DPT (diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus,), $4.56 per dose; DT (diphtheria, tetanus), $0.06 per dose; MMR (measles, mumps, or rubella), $4.44 per dose; and polio, $0.29 per dose. In general, if any vaccine is administered by combining more than one of the listed taxable vaccines, the amount of tax imposed is the sum of the amounts of tax imposed for each taxable vaccine. However, in the case of MMR and its components, any component vaccine of MMR is taxed at the same rate as the MMR-combined vaccine.

Amounts equal to net revenues from this excise tax are deposited in the Vaccine Injury Compensation Trust Fund to finance compensation awards under the Federal Vaccine Injury Compensation Program for individuals who suffer certain injuries following administration of the taxable vaccines. This program provides a substitute Federal, "no fault" insurance system for the State-law tort and private liability insurance systems otherwise applicable to vaccine manufacturers. All persons immunized after September 30, 1998, with covered vaccines must pursue compensation under this Federal program before bringing civil tort actions under State law.


Reasons for Change



The Committee understands that the present-law tax rates applicable to taxable vaccines were chosen to reflect estimated probabilities of adverse reactions and the severity of the injury that might result from such reactions. The Committee understands that medical researchers believe that there is insufficient data to support fine gradations of estimates of potential harm from the various different childhood vaccines. In the light of this scientific assessment, the Committee believes some simplicity can be achieved by taxing such vaccines at the same rate per dose.

The Committee further believes it is appropriate to review the list of taxable vaccines from time to time as medical science advances. The Center for Disease Control has recommended that the vaccines for HIB (haemophilus influenza type B), Hepatitis B, and varicella (chicken pox) be widely administered among the nation's children. In light of the growing number of immunizations using these vaccines, the Committee adds these vaccines to the list of taxable vaccines.


Explanation of Provision



The bill replaces the present-law excise tax rates, that differ by vaccine, with a single rate tax of $0.84 per dose on any listed vaccine component. Thus, the bill provides that the tax applied to any vaccine that is a combination of vaccine components is 84 cents times the number of components in the combined vaccine. For example, the MMR vaccine is to be taxed at a rate of $2.52 per dose and the DT vaccine is to be taxed at rate of $1.68 per dose.

In addition, the provision adds three new taxable vaccines to the present-law taxable vaccines: (1) HIB (haemophilus influenza type B); (2) Hepatitis B; and (3) varicella (chicken pox). The three newly listed vaccines also are subject to the 84-cents per dose excise tax.

Lastly, the Committee directs the Secretary of the Treasury to undertake a study of the efficacy of the new flat-rate vaccine tax system as a means to finance the Vaccine Injury Compensation Trust Fund. Among other issues that the Secretary might find pertinent, the Committee directs the Secretary to explore the following questions. For each taxable vaccine, how does the magnitude of the tax compare to the total price of the vaccine that is charged to the patient (or the patient's insurance company)? Have any changes in the prices of taxable vaccines that might have resulted from the changes in tax enacted by this bill altered the use of taxable vaccines (i.e., what is the price elasticity of demand for the various taxable vaccines)? Does scientific evidence exist to permit a vaccine tax structure that reflects possibly different medical risks from the different vaccines? Does the flat-rate structure generate savings in compliance costs for taxpayers and administrative cost savings for the Internal Revenue Service? The Committee welcomes recommendations regarding possible changes in this tax structure. However, the Committee reminds the Secretary that determination of the tax base and the tax rate are the constitutional prerogative of the Congress and that recommendations for delegation of such authority to the executive branch are inappropriate. The results of the study are to be reported to the Senate Committee on Finance and the House Committee on Ways and Means by September 30, 1999.


Effective Date



The provision is effective for vaccine purchases after September 30, 1997. No floor stocks tax is to be collected or refunds permitted for amounts held for sale on October 1, 1997. Returns to the manufacturer occurring on or after October 1, 1997, are assumed to be returns of vaccines to which the new rates of tax apply.


5. Modify treatment of tires under the heavy highway vehicle retail excise tax (sec. 845 of the bill and sec. 4071 of the Code)




Present Law



A 12-percent retail excise tax is imposed on certain heavy highway trucks and trailers, and on highway tractors. A separate manufacturers' excise tax is imposed on tires weighing more than 40 pounds. This tire tax is imposed as a fixed dollar amount which varies based on the weight of the tire. Because tires are taxed separately, the value of tires installed on a highway vehicle is excluded from the 12-percent excise tax on heavy highway vehicles. The determination of value is factual and has given rise to numerous tax audit challenges.


Reasons for Change



Allowing a credit for the tire tax actually paid on truck tires will simplify the application of the retail truck tax.


Explanation of Provision



The current exclusion of the value of tires installed on a taxable highway vehicle is repealed. Instead, a credit for the amount of manufacturers' excise tax actually paid on the tires is allowed.


Effective Date



The provision is effective after December 31, 1997.


6. Increase tobacco excise taxes (sec. 846 of the bill and sec. 5701 of the Code)




Present Law



The following is a listing of the Federal excise taxes imposed on tobacco products under present law:

                                                                      

                                                                      

   Article                    Tax imposed                             

                                                                      

Cigars:                    

                           

   Small cigars             $1.125 per thousand.                      

                                                                      

                            12.75% of manufacturer's price, up to $30 

   Large cigars             per                                       

                                                                      

thousand.                  

                           

Cigarettes:                

                           

                            $12.00 per thousand (24 cents per pack of 

   Small cigarettes         20                                        

                                                                      

cigarettes).               

                           

   Large cigarettes         $25.20 per thousand.                      

                                                                      

Cigarette papers             $0.0075 per 50 papers.                   

                                                                      

Cigarette tubes              $0.15 per 50 tubes.                      

                                                                      

Chewing tobacco              $0.12 per                                

                                                                      

pound.                     

                           

Snuff                        $0.36 per pound.